Katy Perry’s much-anticipated comeback album, 143, has left fans and critics underwhelmed, raising questions about whether the pop sensation has lost her charm. The US singer, now 39, has been a dominant force in pop music for over a decade, but her latest effort has sparked widespread disappointment, with many branding the album “mediocre” and “generic.” The critical response has led some to label the album a “complete flop.”
Fans of the singer, known for her quirky, colourful persona and catchy tunes, expected her seventh album to reignite the spark that once made her a global icon. Instead, they were met with an album that feels out of touch, especially with younger, edgier artists rising to the top of the charts.
A Shift in Style?
The lead single from 143, “Woman’s World,” has faced particular criticism. Fans have described it as “dated” and lacking the energy that once defined Perry’s music. The music video, which sees Perry and her dancers dressed as construction workers in a parody of ‘girl boss feminism,’ failed to resonate with her audience, leaving many confused about its message.
Adding to the controversy, Perry’s decision to work with producer Dr Luke has not gone unnoticed. Dr Luke, who was embroiled in a highly publicised legal battle with singer Kesha, contributes to nearly every track on the album. This choice has been met with backlash, with both fans and critics questioning Perry’s judgement in collaborating with a figure whose reputation is stained by allegations of abuse.
A Chart Struggle
143 had a tough start on the charts, with “Woman’s World” becoming one of Perry’s worst-performing singles. It debuted at number 63 on the US Billboard Hot 100 and number 47 in the UK, only to fall off the charts soon after. This marks a significant departure from her earlier hits like “Teenage Dream” and “Roar,” which once dominated airwaves and charts alike.
Changing Times
As the pop music landscape evolves, artists like Billie Eilish and Charli XCX have embraced a stripped-back, confessional style that appeals to today’s audience. Perry, on the other hand, seems to be struggling to adapt. While she attempts to embrace a sexier, more sultry image, critics argue that it feels forced and doesn’t resonate with her fanbase.
Variety magazine’s review of 143 summed up the general sentiment, stating, “The album is flat, coasting on lyrical clichés and musical ideas that rarely excite.” Fans have echoed this view, with one commenting, “It lacks the charm and soul of her earlier work.”
A Legacy at Stake?
Perry’s last significant chart success was in 2020 with her album Smile, but even that failed to leave a lasting impact. With 143, it seems Perry’s signature brand of bubblegum pop may have run its course.
Still, as a seasoned performer and global star, Perry’s future remains uncertain. Will she find a way to reinvent herself and reclaim her throne in pop music, or has the “Queen of Quirks” lost her edge for good?
